The Smart Investor's Guide to Stock Options, AMT, and Startup Equity in 2025
👉 Want to learn how to retire without the worry of running out of money in retirement? Click here to watch this video
Stock compensation can be one of the most exciting wealth-building tools for employees—but it’s also one of the most confusing. Terms like RSU, ISO, AMT, and QSBS can feel like an alphabet soup. And if you’re working at a startup or tech company, the stakes are high because these decisions could change your financial future.
Why listen to me?
Stock options and equity compensation can be powerful wealth-building tools—but they come with tax traps that can cost you big if you’re not prepared. In my experience, I’ve seen investors make and lose fortunes because they didn’t understand how RSUs, ISOs, NQSOs, and AMT work together. That’s why I want to break it all down for you in a way that makes sense.
In this guide, I’ll explain:
The different types of stock compensation and who uses them
How AMT (Alternative Minimum Tax) works and how it affects stock options
Why double-trigger RSUs are common in startups
The famous Pets.com AMT disaster and how to avoid a similar fate
The impact of 2025 tax laws on AMT and stock options
How different plans compare to buying stock on your own
Understanding Stock Compensation: RSUs, RSAs, ISOs, NQSOs, and QSBS
Stock compensation isn’t one-size-fits-all. Companies at different stages use different types of stock to attract and retain employees.
What Are RSU, RSA, ISO, NQS, and QSBS?
Companies give special kinds of stock to their employees, but they all work differently:
RSU (Restricted Stock Unit)
A promise to give you stock later. You don’t own it yet. You get it if you stay at the company long enough.
RSA (Restricted Stock Award)
You own the stock right away, but with rules (like having to stay at the company for a period).
ISO (Incentive Stock Option)
A special kind of stock option that can get better tax treatment. However, you might owe AMT (Alternative Minimum Tax) if you hold it too long.
NQS (Non-Qualified Stock Option)
A stock option without special tax benefits. It doesn’t trigger AMT.
QSBS (Qualified Small Business Stock)
If a company is worth under $50 million, this stock might let you pay zero capital gains tax if you hold it long enough.
What Types of Companies Use These?
Different stages of companies prefer different kinds of equity compensation:
Early-Stage Startups
Often use RSAs and ISOs because employees don’t have to pay much upfront to buy stock.
Mid-Stage Startups
Use RSUs and stock options to keep employees happy and encourage them to stay.
Big Public Companies
Like Apple or Google, prefer RSUs because they don’t want early stock grants messing with their earnings reports.
Do Employees Have to Buy These Stocks?
It depends on the type of stock compensation:
ISO (Incentive Stock Options)
Yes, you must buy them out of pocket at a set price (the strike price).
If you hold the shares long enough, you can get capital gains tax treatment instead of paying regular income tax.
Risk: If the stock price drops, you could lose money.
NQS (Non-Qualified Stock Options)
Yes, you must buy them. You pay out of pocket.
Unlike ISOs, NQSOs are taxed as income immediately when bought if the stock has gained value.
QSBS (Qualified Small Business Stock)
Usually given to early investors or founders.
Employees might buy or receive shares for free if they’re early investors or founders.
If held for 5+ years, you can avoid capital gains tax.
RSA (Restricted Stock Awards)
No upfront purchase—they’re given to you.
You own the shares immediately, but with conditions (vesting, staying at the company, etc.).
If you file an 83(b) election, you pay taxes on the stock’s value when you receive it instead of later when it might be worth more.
RSU (Restricted Stock Units)
No purchase required—they’re granted for free but taxed as income when they vest.
How Is This Different From Just Buying Stock on Your Own?
If you buy stock normally (outside of a company plan), you pay the market price and might owe capital gains tax when you sell.
With stock options and RSUs, employees often get discounts or tax advantages that outsiders don’t get.
Is This Like an ESPP (Employee Stock Purchase Plan)?
ESPPs let employees buy company stock at a discount (often 10-15%) through payroll deductions.
Some ESPPs allow employees to sell immediately for an instant gain (known as a “lookback period”).
ESPPs are different from options but still offer unique tax perks.
A Quick Note on Terminology
In this article, we’re using “buy” instead of “exercise” when referring to purchasing stock options. Technically, they mean the same thing, but we’re keeping it simple!
Examples: Why These Are Better Than Just Buying Stock
Here’s how each type of equity can offer advantages:
ISO (Incentive Stock Option)
Advantage: Lower tax rate (capital gains) if held long enough.
Example: Buy at $10 when worth $50. Hold 2+ years, pay 15-20% tax instead of 37% income tax.
NQSO (Non-Qualified Stock Option)
Advantage: No AMT issues; company gets tax deduction.
Example: Buy at $10 when worth $50. Pay income tax on the $40 gain, but the company gets a tax deduction.
RSU (Restricted Stock Unit)
Advantage: Free stock; no upfront cost.
Example: Get 1,000 shares at $50—you pay nothing but owe tax when they vest.
RSA (Restricted Stock Award)
Advantage: Own stock early and reduce taxes with an 83(b) election.
Example: Get 10,000 shares at $0.10, file 83(b), pay tax on $1,000. Later worth $1M. Pay capital gains tax instead of income tax.
ESPP (Employee Stock Purchase Plan)
Advantage: Guaranteed discount + lookback pricing.
Example: Buy at 85% of the lowest price in 6 months. Immediate profit.
QSBS (Qualified Small Business Stock)
Advantage: Pay zero capital gains tax if held 5+ years.
Example: Buy startup stock for $50,000, sell for $2 million after 5 years, pay $0 tax.
When Did Each of These Become Popular?
ISO (Incentive Stock Option)
Created in 1981 (ERTA).
Became popular in the 1980s-1990s, especially in Silicon Valley.
Still used but less common due to AMT issues.
NQSO (Non-Qualified Stock Option)
No specific law.
Popularized in the 1990s as companies found ISO tax rules too strict.
Very common today.
RSU (Restricted Stock Unit)
Became common after 2004 due to accounting changes (FAS 123(R)).
Popular post-2005, especially in big tech.
Most common equity for public companies now.
RSA (Restricted Stock Award)
Always existed, used more after 2004 changes.
Popular for early-stage startups.
Rare in big public companies.
ESPP (Employee Stock Purchase Plan)
Created in 1964.
Popularized in the 1980s-1990s.
Still common in tech and finance.
QSBS (Qualified Small Business Stock)
Created in 1993 to encourage startup investment.
Became more popular after 2010 when IRS allowed 100% tax exclusion.
Huge tax advantage today for founders and early investors.
How AMT Can Sneak Up on You (And How to Avoid It)
What is AMT (Alternative Minimum Tax)?
AMT is a special tax rule to ensure higher-income earners pay at least some tax even if they have many deductions.
If you exercise ISOs and don’t sell the stock, AMT might make you pay taxes before you have cash from selling.
🚨 The Pets.com Example (The Penny Problem)
During the dot-com boom, employees bought ISOs for pennies.
The stock shot up to over $100 per share, triggering huge AMT bills—even though they hadn’t sold yet.
Then the stock crashed to nearly zero. Employees still owed massive AMT bills on paper profits that vanished.
The Rock in the River: Understanding AMT
Think of your taxes as a river and AMT as a big rock:
If your regular tax (the water) is high enough, the rock stays hidden.
If deductions or stock options lower the water, the rock pops out—and you owe AMT.
How This Relates to Stock Options
Most people never see the rock because their regular tax covers it.
But if you exercise ISOs and don’t sell the shares, the IRS sees the “bargain element” as taxable under AMT.
That lowers the water level, revealing the rock (AMT), and you could owe taxes—even if you haven’t sold your stock.
This is what happened to employees during Pets.com—they owed huge AMT bills on stock that became worthless.
How AMT Works with Stock Options Today (2025 Update)
Thanks to the 2017 Tax Cuts and Jobs Act (TCJA), AMT is less of a problem:
Higher AMT exemption limits mean fewer people trigger it.
If you do pay AMT, you may get some back as a credit.
However, ISOs can still trigger AMT if you’re not careful.
What is a Double Trigger?
Many startups attach a “double trigger” to stock like RSUs:
You stay long enough at the company.
The company goes public or gets acquired.
This prevents giving out valuable stock too early before the company knows it’ll succeed.
What is the Bargain Element?
The bargain element is the difference between:
What you pay for the stock (strike price).
The stock’s market value on the day you buy.
Analogy: Buying a house at a discount.
You have the right to buy a house for $100,000. The market value is $500,000. The $400,000 difference is your bargain element—and the IRS may tax it under AMT rules, even if you don’t sell.
Example: Jake buys ISO stock at $5/share when the market says it’s worth $50. That’s a $45 gain per share—or a $225,000 bargain element, taxable under AMT even though Jake hasn’t sold yet.
Final Thoughts: Should You Take Stock Compensation?
Stock compensation can be a powerful way to build wealth—but only if you understand the rules and risks.
Best for Startups: RSA or ISO, because they allow early ownership at a low price.
Best for Public Companies: RSUs or ESPPs, because they’re free or heavily discounted.
Want to minimize taxes? QSBS is the ultimate tax-free wealth builder if you qualify.
Would You Like Help Navigating Your Stock Compensation?
👉 Want to learn how to retire without the worry of running out of money in retirement? Click here to watch this video
FAQs
Q1. Can employees still buy more stock?
Yes, but there are restrictions:
Insider trading rules: If you have non-public info, you can’t buy or sell stock.
Blackout periods: Some companies restrict trading around earnings releases.
Stock ownership limits: Executives over 10% ownership must disclose trades.
401(k) company stock: Some plans allow it, but experts warn about putting too much retirement savings into one company.
Lock-up periods: For private companies going public, early employees often can’t sell stock for 6 months.
Q2. Why not just buy the stock normally?
Discounts & tax perks: Employee plans offer lower prices or tax benefits.
Company perks: Employees may get shares simply for staying employed (RSUs, RSAs).
Big upside: Options let employees lock in lower prices and profit if the stock rises.
Q3. Is AMT still a problem?
AMT is less common post-2017 tax changes.
Still, it’s a risk if you exercise ISOs and hold the shares without selling.
It’s crucial to run projections and plan ahead.
Disclaimer: Case studies are hypothetical and do not relate to an actual client of Lock Wealth Management. Clients or potential clients should not interpret any part of the content as a guarantee of achieving similar results or satisfaction if they engage Lock Wealth Management for investment advisory services.